Episode 169 -- The Latest Thing

Only a couple subjects to cover tonight.  Maybe a brief "get off my lawn" rant on this new Virtual Reality thing.

First let me give you some rather bad news.  Podiobooks.com has been sold to a site called Scribl.  Podiobooks is still there.  Sort of.  The stuff I've already posted is still on that site.  So far.

Thing is, Scribl is all about _selling_ audio versions of books.  Podiobooks was about giving away audio versions of books, and accepting donations, if any.  There weren't many donations, or at least I didn't see many.  Lots of downloads and listeners, not so much with the money.

So, Scribl the sellers of audiobooks, don't accept anything using Creative Commons content.  Can't sell something licensed for only non-commercial use.  And even if I decided my recordings were not so licensed... I use Creative Commons licensed music and sound effects.  I'd have to pay for commercially usable music to support the Public Domain books I record.  And of course I can't afford to do that.

Higher bitrates, that I could manage.  A few minor technical changes, maybe.  Paying money I don't have for audio I don't want to use just doesn't make sense for me.

So while I've been preparing both the books I've been recording for posting to Podiobooks over the months I've been producing them... I can no longer put them on Podiobooks, because Scribl sets the rules there now, and I can't afford to fulfill their requirements.  The only place my recordings of these books will be available will be on my own website.  Which will be disappointing, because I don't have the audience Podiobooks has had.  And I won't be able to do that final stage of posting Mike Hampston's book on Podiobooks, either, because I don't have the right licensing on the music I used to back those recordings, and I don't have the right permissions from the author to put it there anyway.  Not on a commercial site like Scribl.

I suppose I might put the recordings on Librivox.  The old books like Everlasting Man would be fine there.  Don't think I can put Mike's book there.  So all in all, after years of work... that kinda sucks.  I can understand Evo selling the place.  He's not obligated to keep it up just for someone like me.  But that kinda breaks my plans.  And I don't know what to do next.

And that other thing...

I've seen a lot of coverage of all the swell new-ish tech they offer now for trying Virtual Reality.  Got yer basic wrap-around headsets, and special motion controllers and whatnot.  All very shiny, new and expensive.  Tend to require more powerful computers and more powerful graphic cards.  Also very shiny and new.

But once I thought that through, the tech is all that's new.  I've been playing around in a simulated three-dee environment for several years now, Second Life.  No wrap-around goggles, just a keyboard and mouse to control interactions.  But still, it's a three-D environment, albeit rendered in two-D.  To be fair, sure the three-D effect is clever and new.  The fancier controllers are new.  To make all that work you'll need pretty heavy-duty graphics capabilities.  So does Second Life, but I don't think the machine I use for SL could manage that.  I'm sure playing with the new hardware will be fun for a while.

And yet...

What'll happen in these new VR worlds, in a social sense, will not be new.  You'll start with the early adopters, and for a while the only people there will be those people.  Exclusivity has a profound impact on the feel of any social environment, on computers or otherwise.  If you were there, you know that about every previous social site, for as long as there have been computers.  But then, of course, the companies trying to make money off all that will expand, and try to expand their audience.  Crowds of new folks will come.  The builders will come.  And so will the griefers.  The nice folks who treat each other well will be there, for a while.  And the bad folks who treat others evilly will be there, too.

The new tech might allow new ways to interact and experience the environment.  That'll be swell.  But the people will still be people.

So I figure if you want to know how VR in virtual worlds, as compared to 3D video shows from real life, will turn out... you'll come to Second Life.  The anonymity will most likely be the same.  The interactions without apparent consequences will be the same.  The loves will be the same, the hates will be the same.  People will be the same.  Only the technology will be different.

VR will be, they say, immersive.  Second Life is immersive, too.  Takes some time to get used to.  So will VR.  It would be entirely possible to upgrade the existing SL to work somewhat with VR hardware.  It might not work well, but it's liable to be doable.  And for that matter, however hard, it'd likely be quicker and cheaper than building a whole new world from scratch.  Probably won't happen.  But it could.

Anyway, if folks want to know what a real Virtual World, a real Metaverse would be like in a social sense, well, we can show you.  Second Life started out as an experiment in exactly that Metaverse like experience.  Been there, done that, got the virtual teeshirt.

Some of it is wonderful.  Some of the people, in particular, are wonderful.  And some of it sucks.  The sucky parts suck disproportionally to the time and effort involved.  I suppose the same could be said for the wonderful parts.  

I don't think saying any of that will change anyone's opinion of SL.  People who haven't been in SL, or been long enough to actually settle in, have already set their expectations in stone between their ears, and me talking here will probably not make a damn bit of difference.  I don't think much of anyone more will come to SL to find out what VR will turn out to be.  

But it's the truth.  And if anyone is still interested in the truth anymore, this would be a good place to come find some of that particular truth.  We have more than a decade of experience in a laboratory for the beginnings of that same phenomenon.  Some of it will be new.  Most of it will not.

Enjoy the magical new technology and hardware.  But don't expect magical changes to human nature.  Given time, you'll be in a place very much like here.  And from my experience of previous technological advances and changes, it'll probably be much less than what we already have.  

Good night.  And good luck.

 

Show Theme "Hot Swing" from Kevin MacLeod of Incompetech.com.

Comment Line: 218-234-CALL   218-234-2255

Or the "Voicemail" widget on Grizzlysgrowls.com

 Contributions: https://www.paypal.me/grizzlysgrowls

Take the podcast survey, please?   Here's a link for you.

 

Listen now?

Episode 168 - The Everlasting Man by G. K. Chesterton - Part II Chapter III The Strangest Story in the World

Noticed an ironic typo in the title of the current chapter, and had to share that, but went with (probably) the correct version.

Part II On The Man Called Christ

Chapter III The Strangest Story in the World

Book Theme "Deliberate Thought" from Kevin MacLeod of Incompetech.com.

 

Show Theme "Hot Swing" from Kevin MacLeod of Incompetech.com.

 Comments via Audioboo and tag it #HeyGriz

Or the "Voicemail" widget on Grizzlysgrowls.com

 Comment Line: 218-234-CALL   218-234-2255

 Contributions: https://www.paypal.me/grizzlysgrowls

 

 

Listen now?

Episode 167 - The Everlasting Man by G. K. Chesterton - Part II Chapter II The Riddles of the Gospel

Upgraded my computer a bit, new SSD, but I might have done it wrong.  Whole lot of room now, though.  And then, "The Everlasting Man..."

 

Part II On The Man Called Christ

Chapter I The Riddles of the Gospel

Book Theme "Deliberate Thought" from Kevin MacLeod of Incompetech.com.

 

Show Theme "Hot Swing" from Kevin MacLeod of Incompetech.com.

 Comments via Audioboo and tag it #HeyGriz

Or the "Voicemail" widget on Grizzlysgrowls.com

 Comment Line: 218-234-CALL   218-234-2255

 Contributions: https://www.paypal.me/grizzlysgrowls

Listen now?

Episode 166 - The Everlasting Man by G. K. Chesterton - Part II Chapter I The God in the Cave

A little bit on starting work from home.  Still feels odd, but probably good.

 

Part II On The Man Called Christ

Chapter I The God in the cave

Book Theme "Deliberate Thought" from Kevin MacLeod of Incompetech.com.

 

Show Theme "Hot Swing" from Kevin MacLeod of Incompetech.com.

 Comments via Audioboo and tag it #HeyGriz

Or the "Voicemail" widget on Grizzlysgrowls.com

 Comment Line: 218-234-CALL   218-234-2255

 Contributions: https://www.paypal.me/grizzlysgrowls

Listen now?

I was sick today.

I was sick today.

Viral thing.  Basically been sick all week, possibly a couple weeks.  This morning got the full BLAM! of viral.  Called in to work, spent the day sleeping curled up under my usually-winter blanket.

Sad and ironic.  I had lots of time to myself, all day.  And of course the rumor is I'm a podcaster, and one would think all that time would allow me to podcast more.

Except, of course, with a sore throat, coughing and sneezing, talking into a microphone isn't a great option.  Hell, talking ain't my idea of a good time today.  Or these last couple weeks.

Once I'm actually able to speak comfortably again, I'll be back to wishing I could take some ridiculously long period of time to just podcast.  Get both of my book projects finally done with.  I'm down to the last 11 chapters on "Swinging Doors," and I've completed the first half of "The Everlasting Man." 

With some reasonable amount of time, I could actually finish Swinging Doors.   They're short chapters.  Do need to get that recording from Rosie for her part of the one chapter.  But I could do all the rest, and assemble in her portion later.

Everlasting Man, well, keep in mind basically every chapter is an hour long.  If you've ever tried talking for an hour continuously... it's not as easy as it might seem.  And then I have to stop for traffic noises outside, so recording that hour takes maybe two.  Then it takes maybe twice or three times that to do the editing.  I like the book, and frankly, I like the way I sound reading the book.  Till I get to the end of the chapter and start losing my voice.  At least one chapter I really struggled through.  Very ragged sounding.

Try that with a cold.  I'll wait.

So, I got an entire day to myself.  And I slept.  Which was the most I could do.  After a day of that, I don't feel as bad.  I don't feel good, but not as bad.  And I'll go back to work tomorrow and still be coughing and sneezing.  Probably. 

Someone said that a podcast actually is a business.  And I suppose, my podcast is a business.  It's a business at which I don't make any money.  Then again, how many huge businesses these days (cough-Twitter-cough) don't have a good money-making business model ... yet?  So... it's a business.

Sort of.

Could be pointed out that many very successful entrepreneurs started out making no money at all.  Repeatedly.  That's quite true.  It's also true that many, many more have continued to make no money at all for the rest of their lives.  Not like you'd ever hear about them, cause there's really nothing much to hear, is there?

Anyway, I'm sick today.  So, I don't suppose one can expect a positive life outlook, can one?  Maybe tomorrow.

(cough sneeze sniffle)

The Great National Nightmare of Obfusition

Today I decided to create a new word for the English language: OBFUSITION.  It is a term for a debating technique that is deliberately deeply offensive.  Those who use this technique think it's okay, because everyone is being deeply offensive.  If it's not deeply offensive, it's un-American.

Obfusition is a portmanteau of obfuscation and opposition. 
ob·fus·cate
ˈäbfəˌskāt/
verb
    render obscure, unclear, or unintelligible.
op·po·si·tion
ˌäpəˈziSH(ə)n/
noun
    resistance or dissent, expressed in action or argument.

Simply put, Obfusition is the use of obfuscation rather than an actual response to oppose an argument.

Note I used obfuscation, and not obscuration, because fewer people know the word obfuscation and thus it is ever so much more clever and pretentious-sounding.

Obfusition is a superset of an old concept called a "straw man argument."  According to Wikipedia, "A straw man is a common form of argument and is an informal fallacy based on giving the impression of refuting an opponent's argument, while actually refuting an argument that was not advanced by that opponent."  If your opponent says something to which you don't have a response, you say or imply they said something else, and respond to that.  If you succeed, they respond to your straw man and defend the position they never actually took, rather than sticking to their original point, so you win.

Obfusition is easier than a full straw man.  In it's simplest form, you hang a loud and offensive label on your opponent's argument -- or on your opponent.  If that label, that meme, is loud enough and offensive enough, your opponent may not be able to respond at all, being so deeply angered and offended. 

Further, many of the labels commonly used in obfusition tend to cause knee-jerk, devisive reactions from your audience.  Your supporters and those of your opponent start screeching and throwing poo at each other, unless they didn't actually bring poo to the debate, then they just screech.  Often, no more words are necessary; they won't be understood in any case.  There are no longer any English speakers in the room.

Obfusitions can be unreasonably powerful, because the use of some obfusitions implies your opponent is not allowed to respond, and for that matter, may not be allowed to be offended.  Many obfusitions are taken as true on face value, so emotionally fraught with connotations that the audience believes they must be absolutely true because they've been stated.  Then the obfusitionist need only offer reasons why one ought to agree with the obfusition.  Your opponent's original statement is not, and often can not be, intelligently discussed any further.

It should also be noted that the word "obfusition" is recursive.  Calling an argument an obfusition may be an obfusition.

Also, many obfusitions are abuses of clever and trendy words, phrases and memes that previously had a very specific meaning, referring to one and only one sort of behavior.  Use the obfusition for any given behavior, and It Must Be True, because the word or phrase is familiar and clever-sounding, even if the original meaning is forgotten and has nothing to do with what actually happened.  "But he liked so well having thought of it, he says again, Good Fences Make Good Neighbors."

One reason, I believe, that obfusitions are so impactful, is that they trigger something fundamental in the "lizard brain."  Humans are genetically still those wild creatures that ran naked on the plains, or in the jungles, mountains or forests, chasing down and clubbing other creatures to death with sticks and stones and eating their flesh raw, peeing and pooing wherever they happen to be.

One concept from the lizard brain we follow at a level long before thought, is "Us and Them."  We detect others of Us by sight, smell, actions and rarely speech.  Someone said somewhere that the name every tribe has for itself translates literally as "The People."  It follows that if we are People, they are not People.  Essentially every war is begun by convincing Us that They are not Like Us.  They are not Human.  Therefore, killing them is okay, and may even be required.

Our storytellers have vast influence, harkening back to the early Shaman who told the stories of The People, demonstrating by example what We do and how We do it.  If you don't do what we do according to the stories, You are not one of Us.  We should kill you.  Even if a storyteller intends some entirely different message, the Story impacts how we perceive the normal behavior of The People.  Some homework for you.  Consider horror stories in this context.

An effective obfusition applied to you makes you Them, not Us, not one of the People, not a Human.  We should not listen to you. If you keep talking, we should shout you down and chase you away.  Taken further, perhaps we should injure or kill you.

Again, we have never stopped being those wild, naked, vicious creatures.  Our children are born as exactly those creatures, and only those creatures.  Look closely, and you will see exactly that behavior in kids, Us versus Them, fighting to be the King of the Mountain, the Alpha.  We have learned over the millenia, and learned to teach our children, to refrain from those lizard responses.  It is not remarkable, in my opinion, that some of our children become killers.  It is truly miraculous that most children do not.  Somehow we make that happen.  Mostly.

So.  Obfusition.  I truly hesitate at a visceral level to use any examples.  Doubtless some of my audience will start screeching and throwing poo at each other.

Elitist.  Intellectual. Idiot. Liberal.  Conservative.  Communist.  Fascist. Nazi.  Racist. Insert here all the racist epithets you can remember, there are a lot of them.  Paranoid. Atheist.   Further expanding the list is left as an exercise for the Reader.

And just for fun, let me offer a derivative obfusition.  "Mansplanation."  It has a specific meaning, you can Google it for yourself.  And is clever sounding.  If what you're opposing is not that specific phenomenon, even if it is in fact a man offering an explanation, even if one or more of the audience are female... it's an obfusition.  And yes, I am male, last time I checked.

Here, you can have your poo back.

UPON FURTHER REVIEW: I thought of a related term, "Obfumation."  Affirmation via Obfuscation. Make your position sound like something positive by naming it something that doesn't reflect what you're actually saying, e.g., "Alt Right."

Further Deponent Sayeth Not.

Recapitulating Aggregation... Okay, right... wait, what?

Back when Yahoo! Pipes was working, I created a half-dozen different aggregate RSS feeds.  Some were kind of fun ideas.

Today I grabbed my old lists and played with a site called RSSMix to recreate a bunch of them, cause they used to be quite popular.

BLOGS -- MNVoices Aggregate Feed An aggregation of the latest posts from all the Blogs of participants in the Minnesota Voices Online UnConference.  The UnConference was way, way long ago, but the blogs appear to still be active.  Including mine, you'll notice.

My Chesterton on Podiobooks    All the Chesterton books in particular that I've posted to Podiobooks.  Everlasting Man isn't on there quite yet, that's only half done.  And as it works out, the current four books are on there in book order, starting with Heretics.

The NaNaPooPoo Network   After that one year when I completed National Podcast Post Month and National Blog Post Month, having done aggregate feeds for both, I decided to create NaNaPooPoo, an ad hoc network of podcasts all available in one feed.  Was originally just podcasts from NaPodPoMo (that's where the name came from).  Anyway, never really went anywhere.

With Pipes, I could have the feed only include the one latest post from each feed, even if the latest from one feed, say, might be a couple months old.  With the current setup, it'll just put all the items in chronological order.  Ain't the same.  But they're back in one-big-aggregate format, so it's something.

Enjoy.